We’ve all heard of couples who can’t have kids of their own adopting babies. The adopted babies are often orphans, and sometimes they’re abandoned by their own mothers who give them away to escape the social stigma of giving birth out of wedlock (disgusting but factual).
A relative of mine, let’s call her Filana, has been married for 10 years. She and her husband, Filan, have been trying to get pregnant for years but haven’t had any luck. Finally, they decided to adopt a child. Last year, when she asked for my opinion, I was so excited and suggested we go together to the Mygoma Orphanage where she can take one of the kids home with her. I also suggested that we first visit a farm that I used to volunteer at, conveniently located at a walking distance from my house, where the Mygoma kids are often sent to receive hippotherapy. There, I told her, she can meet the children, interact with them and make a final decision whether or not she wants to go through with this. I was certain that one look at these beautiful children will be enough to prompt Filana to take one home with her.
A few weeks later, there was a buzz about Filana and Filan finally adopting a baby girl. As predicted, family members’ reactions ranged between approving and critical. I thought that Filana may have gone to the Mygoma without me, nevertheless I was very thrilled for her and her husband. They were finally going to be happy.
After a few days passed, I met Filana at a family gathering and she introduced me to Filana, Jr., an adorable baby girl she was feeding milk to out of a bottle. She looked too tiny, may have been 1-month old. I started a conversation with her enquiring about her experience.
Me: So, how was it at the orphanage? Your first time, wasn’t it? It must’ve been really emotional for you. It can’t be easy having to choose which child you will end up giving a home to while leaving the rest behind. Picking out one baby out of hundreds, I can’t imagine the agony of it…
Filana: Oh, it wasn’t that bad. I was even luckier than I thought. I didn’t even have to go to this orphanage you always talk about.
Me: I see, did you go to another orphanage?
Filana: Actually, Filana, Jr. is my husband’s niece. Her biological father, Faloon, is my husband’s brother. His wife was pregnant, and they already had three girls. Faloon promised my husband that if his wife delivers a fourth girl this time, he will give her to us. Alhamdulillah, it was a girl and Faloon kept his word. She is ours now.
Me *flabbergasted*: Mabrook ya Hinaya. I mean ya Filana.
I went home that day with three thoughts consuming my head, in addition to the huge “WTF” that accompanied me for days to come.
1) Ordinary people give away their babies now? Perfectly healthy babies who are their own flesh and blood? And for what? For common courtesy? Is this a whole new level of Sudanese hospitality? Did the lady go, “God has blessed me with three little ones already, you need this one more than I do... take my baby, I insist!” Did Faloon tell his brother, “Wallahi as long as I’m alive and breathing, and have a kid to spare, you won’t set foot in that orphanage... take my baby, I insist!”
2) What about the hundreds of babies at the Mygoma Orphanage? What about babies left at the gate of the orphanage and others found on the streets? Do they know how many of the 1,500 abandoned babies every year end up surviving and how many die? Was there a lack in children who needed a home, food and clothing that prompted Filana and her husband to resort to taking a baby who already had a family?
3) What about Filana, Jr.? Won't she resent her parents for giving her away, even if to her own uncle? How confused will her life be, having an uncle for a father and a father for an uncle? How will she explain this to her friends growing up? What about her three sisters, is seeing them once a week the same as growing up with them, playing with them, having them around? How unfair is this to her?
While some of you may think it was Filana’s right to opt for the baby with the less complications and the unstained reputation who will not cause her and her husband any problems in the future given its origin, I, on the other hand, ask you this: when did beggars become choosers? And why is it okay for this to happen? How messed up must our community be to accept for a mother to give her child away to a stranger, and reject for another childless woman dying to become a mother to take in an illegitimate child? Why is the former considered a heroine and the latter a crazy b****? And how messed up must we be to abide by these messed up rules that can in no way be traced to religion?
What we need to do is grow up, stand up for what we believe in and fight these hypocritical laws, instead of robotically following them in order to conform, wanting so badly to be accepted by a society that puts blame on innocent children whose only fault is being born into a cruel, cruel world.
Note to Sudanese unmarried couples having unprotected sex: Either use protection, practice abstinence or move to another country that has more tolerance for illegitimate babies.
Tweet
nas hinaya/filana dail.. r they for real?!
ReplyDeletethat will be one confusing situation in a few years!
i hope this doesn't become a trend!
am a doctor work in Almaigoma and almost nom ber of children a about 270 children and we receive about 20 children per week comparing with one child adopted per week its very sad Statistics
ReplyDeletevery interesting account Mimz.
ReplyDeletecertainly think there is a high element of irregularity to this story. Being pregnant and giving up one's child is a most strange idea. These must be very folksy people that are your relatives. It's repugnant.
I fail to fault your relative for adopting her husband's niece. The problem with this "transaction" is not the buyer but the seller. What is most primitive is that your relative's husband's brother would give their new born daughter away because "she's another girl." Quite strange stuff. Quite disgusting actually.
This story poses a tricky dilemma. How do members of a community express moral outrage while respecting the privacy of familial decisions. Sadly, in Sudan, we deal with many such problems.
but a word of correction: don't call them illegitimate babies. Many abandoned or denied orphans might be born out of wedlock but they are not illegitimate. The case you've recounted is definitely a peculiar one but I do not think it is totally uncommon. A very special white American mentor of mine from the United States told me he was raised by his mother (which was his biological mother's sister) and all his life he called his biological mother his aunt. I was shocked when I first heard this.
Legitimacy and Illegitimacy: An archaic social construct with noble roots
This nobility of being born in wedlock has its virtues. However, we should be careful about describing those who had no hand in being the product of an extra-marital engagement as "illegitimate." That is step 1 in combating discrimination... be careful how we call and view things. For was it not Jesus Christ and Mohamed (Peace be Upon them) who told us to mind the poor and the orphans.
Thanks for sharing Mimz!
we have many cases of children raised by their relatives in here and it is weird indeed but generally they can manage its a sad thing... people need to open their mind and governments need to help these poor children
ReplyDeleteAsalaamu Alaykum wa rahmatAllahi wa Barakatu
ReplyDeleteHope you are in good Health and Imaan Ameen.
But Dayum ya Mimz! Nicely written! This is shocking stuff I've never heard of before. Truly Shocking!
Also nice Blog mashAllaaah, Keep it up Sister JazakAllaahu Khayre wa BarekAllaahu Feek, Ws.
ReplyDeleteWell written Mimz. I have encountered 2 similar cases in my life.
ReplyDeleteThe first encounter was with an Indian friend of mine, where when @ uni he told me that his parents donated his sister to his uncle and aunt, who, similarly to your situation, were unable to bear children. It took some time for me to absorb what she was telling me because I really couldn't comprehend how somebody could simply give away their child. However they all lived in the same house or in 2 adjacent apartments. Well whatever they were in close proximity to each other so they were still always with their daughter. The shocking thing was that at the time, my friends sister did not know that her father was her uncle, and her uncle was her father! I met up with my friend some years later and I asked him if they broke the news to his sister/cousin, and he told me they did. I didn't interrogate him further regarding his sisters reaction upon being confronted with this news.
The second encounter this time was a Sudanese friend of mine abroad who had been raised by her aunt and uncle, whereas her biological parents were still alive and kicking in Sudan. Again, I was completely flabbergasted as to how somebody could simply donate their child away. Notice that their child was going away to a foreign country where they would have no or little interaction with her.
I don't like to judge, and I'm not in these peoples shoes. I'm sure adopting is not an easy thing to do, which is why the reward for it is so great. "Ana wa kafil alyateemi kahatan filjanna" But I would like to think that I would have the ability to adopt a poor orphaned/abandoned child into my home and provide him/her with the loving home that every child deserves. I really do despise some of our ridiculously judgmental, unfounded and illogical Sudanese customs and traditions. And really hate how well educated people blindly follow these customs simply because we're Sudanese. Islam came to abolish all of these nonsensical cultural traditions, yet we still are determined to override local culture over Islamic culture.
Rabana ya9li7 Alsudan walSudaniyeen. Again thanks for the enjoyable reads you provide. Keep up the good work :)
you are amazing!
ReplyDeletei relate to this story because i have an aunt who never had children for 30 years of marriage and when she decided to adopt (kafalt yateem) everyone was against her! but she didn't give up. and now she adopted 2 beautiful boys not one! she is courageous and strong. and now they hint that wouldn't it be better if she took her sisters daughter or son and helped her sister instead of taking a stranger illegitimate baby under her roof!!!??? while in religion people who adopt and i mean (kafalt yateem) are awarded greatly... so where is their reason? the got none!
actually, this isn't a new trend. my grandmother gave birth to my dad exactly 10 months after his older brother was born, and she gave him away to a relative who couldn't have children. she asked for him back after a few days, but the point is that zaman they didn't have orphanages. if a child was unwanted or would not be taken care of well, it's better it go to a home that will appreciate it. on the other hand, if a relative couldn't have children, their only option was adopting from another relative. you can consider it kindness. life was so communal then that they're probably all in the same house anyway. but i agree that the stigma against orphans needs to go. our outrage shouldn't be misplaced, though.
ReplyDeleteI have another concern, was Filana Jr's Mother involved in this agreement?? I totally doubt!! I know a similar case of a now grown up woman who refuses to visit her mother for more than 20 years now because she gave her at the age of 2 to her sister, who ended up treating the girl badly after because of unknown reasons!!.. life is complicated and Sudanese make it more complicated!
ReplyDeleteThanks mimz for the great - yet shocking - blog!
ok so I randomly stumbled upon this blog and my reaction when reading this story was literally saying WTF loudly. I mean seriously? Maygoma and all the shocking stories behind it and the documentaries about it were very shocking but this is a new level. First of all, give your child to your brother cause u have three already? and even worse than that giving your child to your brother because she is a GIRL, and if she was not a GIRL then you would keep the little precious BOY? this just makes me sick.What happened to sudan ya jama3a what happened to my country????? I'm the daughter of a Sudanese man who has only two daughters and I swear to god he wanted not a single more child although my mom wanted to try having a boy but he told her his daughters are enough. Either the society really really crumbled down back in Sudan or my father is a very different man. This post seriously made me love my parents even more, and yea I'm gonna continue reading this blog. Thank you so much for writing about such issues please continue to give us insight from Sudan.
ReplyDelete